Supreme Court Lawyer Tom Goldstein Jailed Six Years Over Poker-Linked Fraud
Tom Goldstein, one of America’s most recognisable Supreme Court attorneys, has been sentenced to six years in prison after a Maryland federal jury found him guilty of tax evasion and mortgage fraud connected to his secret career as a high-stakes poker player.
Goldstein, 56, was convicted in February on 12 of the 16 counts he faced. According to reporting by Casino.org, the charges related to millions of dollars in poker winnings on which he failed to pay tax, as well as dishonest statements made on mortgage applications.
As a lawyer, Goldstein built an exceptional reputation, arguing more than 40 cases before the US Supreme Court. He was also part of Al Gore’s legal team during the landmark Bush v. Gore case following the 2000 presidential election. Away from the courtroom, however, he was quietly competing in some of the world’s biggest heads-up cash games, winning and losing tens of millions of dollars over the years.
The most dramatic chapter of his poker career came in 2016, when he played a series of heads-up matches against three wealthy opponents — private equity billionaire Alec Gores and two gamblers identified in court only as “the Chairman” and “Tango.” Testimony at trial indicated those matches produced around $50 million in winnings, though Goldstein had sold 75% of his action to backers, leaving him with roughly a quarter of any profits. He ultimately claimed to have lost around $10 million playing poker over the course of his career.
Goldstein pleaded not guilty throughout, arguing that any tax underreporting was the result of honest mistakes by himself, his accountant, or office managers. He became emotional at sentencing, telling the judge: “There is no question that I have deeply disappointed people.”
Prosecutors had pushed for an eight-year term, while his defence argued that probation and restitution would be more appropriate, citing what they described as “a severe and longstanding gambling addiction.” Judge Lydia Kay Griggsby settled on six years, acknowledging his charitable contributions, including co-founding the widely respected SCOTUSblog, while calling his conduct “serious and concerning.”
Goldstein is expected to appeal both his conviction and his sentence.
This case serves as a stark reminder that gambling winnings — however they are generated — carry legal tax obligations in the jurisdictions where they arise. For anyone interested in how gambling laws and player responsibilities shape the wider industry, our casino news section covers the latest developments, and our guides section offers practical information on staying informed.
Gambling should always be approached responsibly. If you or someone you know is affected by problem gambling, visit BeGambleAware.org. 18+.